This has happened to me and the emotions and feelings are so intense.
September 11th, 2008 - 6:42ambp said...
i love it msg me and tell me all about it
October 23rd, 2008 - 4:29amRachel said...
I watched the show and thought it was more sensational than educational, and flawed in its basic approach. The German forced children into this world with birth defects and a lifetime of shame ahead of them. Why didn't the documentary follow something they mentioned only briefly -- that the brother was taken into care because of a traumatic family situation? Perhaps it wasn't so much genetic sexual attraction, but childhood abuse and fear of being alone that pushed them together into that relationship. It was like they were desperate for a family situation. Why didn't the psychologists discuss it? As for the mother-son couple -- well, one could speculate that a girl giving birth at 14 was having some serious problems early on. She wasn't asked anything about the circumstances of her son's conception/forcible adoption. Nor do we know what kind of lives mother and son led before they met. Maybe they were also emotionally fragile, like the German couple seemed to be.
October 27th, 2008 - 4:06amRob said...
I can relate. How can I view this documentary? Particularly the Steve and Diane story. Because I'm in the U.S. ITV won't allow me to watch the clip. Please help! Thank you.
November 9th, 2008 - 4:28amstephen said...
Just leave it alone
November 22nd, 2008 - 12:13amana said...
by nature and religion i think it is wrong 4 2 family members 2 be in a relationship and sexualy engaged with some one they share blood with but i also think that if the feelings are mutual then so let it be but with most people the idea of bein in love with ur own family member(s) wether a brother/sister or half brother/sister is upsetting, disgusting and so on and so forth but i think there is a whole other side 2 it. not that i'm against the person types mentioned bellow but only makin a point. . . y is it that in our human lives we have so far except gay people,transexuals,transvestines and there are also people out there whom take part in sexual ingagement with creatures/animals (which personaly i find it more sickening then the subject at handand) yet people seem 2 except that more than this issue.
We need 2 except all the different kinds of lives people choose 2 live and the ways they choose it.we are supportive 2 most other people which chose other ways and that are still wrong in life for the same reasons, then y can't we except this ???? we have learned 2 live with a lot more worser things such as fathers/adults molesting their own kidz or some1 elses, people that rape babys as young as 3 month, and yet these pople live amongst us. SOOOOOO PEOPLE LEAVE WITH IT.... It deeply upset me wen i saw the young German couple walkin down the stairs and a neighbour cursing at them then turned violent on the young man which naturaly any1's instinct wud b 2 protect their own family despite how they r seen (even the more reason 4 them 2 b deffensive).as the saying goes" what goes around comes around " if u do something wrong 2 some1 then eventually something wrong will happen 2 u. its just a way of life and i'm prety sure his neighbour will pay the price at some point. I wish 2 support people with these situations as we are humans and we all have made many mistakes so this shud b 1 of those we shud learn 2 except . . . . . .
November 23rd, 2008 - 6:44pmSimon said...
I'm so glad that the incest taboo is being approached in the media, frankly in this day and age, with homosexuality etc being legal i would have thoguht people would have come around to legalizing CONSENSUAL ADULT relationships, no matter who they are with. I mean god, sadism relationships are legal because they are CONSENTING and ADULT about it. Get over it. Lord. The children were perfectly healthy and happy in their family, if not for their father being imprisoned and breaking up the family every three years.
December 3rd, 2008 - 3:07amC said...
I think it's HOT!!!!
January 5th - 2:45amLizzie said...
My brother and I were placed for adoption at a very early age. We just found each other.
I feel a complete unconditional love I have never experienced before from anyone.
He and I are very attracted to each other but I am trying my best to act like a sister.
He has visited me and I will go visit him
next month, he lives way out in the middle of no where, we will be all alone. I pray for the strength to be only his sister and no more. I had canceled my plans but other family members insist I owe him a visit. He was very disappointed I had canceled, no one knew why, but I feel obligated now. I feel so shy about being all alone with him for a week though in my heart that's what I want. People who have not been through this cannot understand that this love is pure. I do want to be strong though and I will try my best. I need your prayers, thanks.
After my divorce at 45. my brother came to visit me very often. Soon I had also eelings for him and now we live together like man and wife.
February 5th - 8:47pmmon said...
because of sick crap like this is why this world and most of the sickos in it are all going to hell!!! it is also why we keep getting new generations of sickos...just goes on & on, a big dysfunctional f#@@**ked up world! like most of u that wrote ur crap comments here! what is the world coming to, my god!?!
February 26th - 4:27amLindsey said...
It's wrong in every way.
Scientifically speaking, (with all religious, natural and social beliefs aside) if you have kids they are not born like other kids. They can't function like us because they are incest children, and they are missing chromosomes that they would usually get from another partner who doesn't share the same blood and family history as you do. The child is a sign from nature, from god and from science to say that children are made this way to stop people from making children with direct family members. Get a life....NOT one with your brother/sister.
IF LOVE IS UNCONDITIONAL IT DOESNT MATTER WERE IT COMES FROM LIVE YOUR LIFE AND THEY WILL LIVE THEIRS ITS NO BIG DEAL. PPL ARE WAY TO JUDGE MENTAL. BEING DIFFERENT DOESNT MAKE YOU A FREAK IT MAKES YOU UNIQUE
May 25th - 4:20amMs. Johnson said...
I just finished watching this documentary on BBC and decided to do some Google research. I found this article and wanted to share it with you since I know you like to read!!!!
August 10th - 3:44amCamilla Downing said...
For those who are citing religion as a reason to ban incest -- what about in Genesis when Adam and Eve left the garden of Eden? How do you think the world was populated? They had children and the children had sex with each other. So technically and religiously speaking, we're all "incest children"! Also, after the great flood, Noah and his family were all that were left, so AGAIN we have an instance where the world was repopulated via incest. And that's what religion has to say about THAT.
Add a comment
Brothers and Sisters in Love is a Documentary programme.
Comments
GAYYYYYYYYY FREAKS
This has happened to me and the emotions and feelings are so intense.
i love it msg me and tell me all about it
I watched the show and thought it was more sensational than educational, and flawed in its basic approach. The German forced children into this world with birth defects and a lifetime of shame ahead of them. Why didn't the documentary follow something they mentioned only briefly -- that the brother was taken into care because of a traumatic family situation? Perhaps it wasn't so much genetic sexual attraction, but childhood abuse and fear of being alone that pushed them together into that relationship. It was like they were desperate for a family situation. Why didn't the psychologists discuss it? As for the mother-son couple -- well, one could speculate that a girl giving birth at 14 was having some serious problems early on. She wasn't asked anything about the circumstances of her son's conception/forcible adoption. Nor do we know what kind of lives mother and son led before they met. Maybe they were also emotionally fragile, like the German couple seemed to be.
I can relate. How can I view this documentary? Particularly the Steve and Diane story. Because I'm in the U.S. ITV won't allow me to watch the clip. Please help! Thank you.
Just leave it alone
by nature and religion i think it is wrong 4 2 family members 2 be in a relationship and sexualy engaged with some one they share blood with but i also think that if the feelings are mutual then so let it be but with most people the idea of bein in love with ur own family member(s) wether a brother/sister or half brother/sister is upsetting, disgusting and so on and so forth but i think there is a whole other side 2 it. not that i'm against the person types mentioned bellow but only makin a point. . . y is it that in our human lives we have so far except gay people,transexuals,transvestines and there are also people out there whom take part in sexual ingagement with creatures/animals (which personaly i find it more sickening then the subject at handand) yet people seem 2 except that more than this issue.
We need 2 except all the different kinds of lives people choose 2 live and the ways they choose it.we are supportive 2 most other people which chose other ways and that are still wrong in life for the same reasons, then y can't we except this ???? we have learned 2 live with a lot more worser things such as fathers/adults molesting their own kidz or some1 elses, people that rape babys as young as 3 month, and yet these pople live amongst us. SOOOOOO PEOPLE LEAVE WITH IT.... It deeply upset me wen i saw the young German couple walkin down the stairs and a neighbour cursing at them then turned violent on the young man which naturaly any1's instinct wud b 2 protect their own family despite how they r seen (even the more reason 4 them 2 b deffensive).as the saying goes" what goes around comes around " if u do something wrong 2 some1 then eventually something wrong will happen 2 u. its just a way of life and i'm prety sure his neighbour will pay the price at some point. I wish 2 support people with these situations as we are humans and we all have made many mistakes so this shud b 1 of those we shud learn 2 except . . . . . .
I'm so glad that the incest taboo is being approached in the media, frankly in this day and age, with homosexuality etc being legal i would have thoguht people would have come around to legalizing CONSENSUAL ADULT relationships, no matter who they are with. I mean god, sadism relationships are legal because they are CONSENTING and ADULT about it. Get over it. Lord. The children were perfectly healthy and happy in their family, if not for their father being imprisoned and breaking up the family every three years.
I think it's HOT!!!!
My brother and I were placed for adoption at a very early age. We just found each other.
I feel a complete unconditional love I have never experienced before from anyone.
He and I are very attracted to each other but I am trying my best to act like a sister.
He has visited me and I will go visit him
next month, he lives way out in the middle of no where, we will be all alone. I pray for the strength to be only his sister and no more. I had canceled my plans but other family members insist I owe him a visit. He was very disappointed I had canceled, no one knew why, but I feel obligated now. I feel so shy about being all alone with him for a week though in my heart that's what I want. People who have not been through this cannot understand that this love is pure. I do want to be strong though and I will try my best. I need your prayers, thanks.
After my divorce at 45. my brother came to visit me very often. Soon I had also eelings for him and now we live together like man and wife.
because of sick crap like this is why this world and most of the sickos in it are all going to hell!!! it is also why we keep getting new generations of sickos...just goes on & on, a big dysfunctional f#@@**ked up world! like most of u that wrote ur crap comments here! what is the world coming to, my god!?!
It's wrong in every way.
Scientifically speaking, (with all religious, natural and social beliefs aside) if you have kids they are not born like other kids. They can't function like us because they are incest children, and they are missing chromosomes that they would usually get from another partner who doesn't share the same blood and family history as you do. The child is a sign from nature, from god and from science to say that children are made this way to stop people from making children with direct family members. Get a life....NOT one with your brother/sister.
IF LOVE IS UNCONDITIONAL IT DOESNT MATTER WERE IT COMES FROM LIVE YOUR LIFE AND THEY WILL LIVE THEIRS ITS NO BIG DEAL. PPL ARE WAY TO JUDGE MENTAL. BEING DIFFERENT DOESNT MAKE YOU A FREAK IT MAKES YOU UNIQUE
I just finished watching this documentary on BBC and decided to do some Google research. I found this article and wanted to share it with you since I know you like to read!!!!
For those who are citing religion as a reason to ban incest -- what about in Genesis when Adam and Eve left the garden of Eden? How do you think the world was populated? They had children and the children had sex with each other. So technically and religiously speaking, we're all "incest children"! Also, after the great flood, Noah and his family were all that were left, so AGAIN we have an instance where the world was repopulated via incest. And that's what religion has to say about THAT.